Solenoid Problems -- Diagnosing Car Electrical Problems Properly

95

By Benjimester

Solenoid Problems

Solenoid problems are a very often hidden problem that can cause quite a bit of electrical problems.  Most people have never heard of a solenoid, and when their vehicles start having electrical problems they automatically assume that the battery or the starter is dead.  Very possibly, the solenoid could have gone bad.  A solenoid is generally just a coil of wire that's wrapped around a hollow non-magnetic core. The solenoid receives an electric current from both the ignition switch as well as the battery.  The small electric current from the ignition switch forces the solenoid to clamp together a pair of heavy contacts.  This allows the large electric current from the battery to flow to the starter and turn over the engine. Generally, when a solenoid gets broken, the two metal clamps won't operate anymore to complete the circuit, making it impossible for power to flow from the battery. 

Solenoid problems can be diagnosed by bridging the connection between the two posts to allow electricity to flow from the battery to the starter.
Solenoid problems can be diagnosed by bridging the connection between the two posts to allow electricity to flow from the battery to the starter.

Diagnosing Solenoid Problems

If your car won't start and you've changed your battery or jumped it, and if there's no sound at all out of the starter when you turn the key, then it's a good bet that your solenoid is bad.  Depending on the solenoid, you may or may not be able to test it.  The solenoid's job is simple, it connects the circuit between the battery and the starter.  So when a solenoid is broken, it no longer is able to connect the battery to the starter.  So testing a solenoid is just a matter of bridging the connection and allowing power to flow from the battery to the starter.  If you have a metal tool with a rubber handle, you can touch both of the posts with the metal, thus bridging the connection and allowing power to flow.  Just be sure not to shock yourself.  This will not work in every case however, because solenoids are different and not all of them have easily accessed ports like this.

We once had a riding lawnmower with a bad solenoid and would keep a long screwdriver in the glove box to use every time we needed to start it.  We would reach in and touch the screwdriver to both the ports on the solenoid, and without fail, the lawnmower would start right up every time.  We eventually changed out the solenoid, but since the solenoid is a very simple part that only functions to bridge the connection between the battery and the starter, we figured it wasn't that big of a deal.  In fact, having an easily accessible faulty solenoid is actually quite a good anti theft system.

How Does a Solenoid Break?

The solenoid can break through a variety of factors.  One factor is just normal wear and tear which causes all automotive components to eventually wear out.  Another factor that can cause a solenoid to go bad is poor technique in jump starting a car.  If you have jump started your car recently or helped a friend jump start theirs, then it's possible that you've accidentally knocked out your solenoid.  If when the jumper cables are hooked up to your battery posts, you accidentally touch the copper of the other two jumper cables together, it'll send a spike of power through your system that can knock out your solenoid.  This generally happens to the car that's doing the jump starting and not the one with the dead battery.  Generally poor jump starting technique happens when a person hooks up the cables to the powered battery first, and then while walking over to hook up the dead car, the heads of the other two cables touch, thus sending a surge through the system which either knocks out the solenoid, or else weakens it so that it becomes faulty and fails at a later date.  So don't ever touch the heads of the jumper cables together.

Replacing a Bad Solenoid

If you've gotten a faulty solenoid and you want to replace it, it should be a fairly simple process, depending on whether or not it's buried under other components.  If your electrical system is constantly acting up and you've already replaced the battery and don't know what to do, it might be a good idea to slowly start replacing the rest of the starter system.  The solenoid is a good place to start because it's a small part with little installation.  If you go into your local auto parts store and find the solenoid you need for your car, they should be able to give you further instructions on how to install that particular solenoid into your vehicle.  Just make sure you disconnect your battery first so that you don't accidentally shock yourself.

Comments

BenjaminB 16 months ago

Benji it's a good idea if the solenoid goes out to at least buy and have ready a new starter as well. Most mechanics will tell you that when the Solenoid goes out the starter will not be far behind. You can also jump a starter if you can get to the solenoid by arcing a long screwdriver from the positive post to the frame with the key turned in the on position. I had a semi that I started like that for over 4 months until I had enough money to replace the solenoid and the starter all in one shot.

Benjimester profile image

Benjimester Hub Author 16 months ago

Ben, that's an awesome tip. I had no idea you could do that. I'd like to see that in action sometime :) And that's a good tip about having a new starter on hand as well. I can see how if one system fails, the others down the line won't be far behind. I hope you've been well. I haven't seen you in awhile. I'm off to see what you've been writing recently!

BenjaminB 16 months ago

Benji the first time a buddy of mine showed me how to do that, when my truck was having starting problems,it freaked me out completely,lol. I was afraid I was going to get the wazoo shocked out of me,but it's no big deal. It will throw a pretty good spark and scare you if you don't get the screwdriver pressed down in good contact with the frame or brush it on anything else while trying. I never actually got shocked doing it though.

Benjimester profile image

Benjimester Hub Author 16 months ago

Haha, that's awesome. It would have freaked me out as well. Sparks are always fun when gasoline is close by :)

lefseriver profile image

lefseriver 16 months ago

I have always considered the solenoid to be a mystery part; but if you conjectured that something was wrong and said, 'must be the solenoid', you appeared to know something about car mechanics.

Benjimester profile image

Benjimester Hub Author 16 months ago

Yeah I think you're right about it being somewhat of a mystery part. Since it has both a physical and an electrical response, it can be a bit tricky. But if the engine won't start and you use a screwdriver to bridge the solenoid ports, then you can be pretty well sure that it's your solenoid that's bad if the engine starts :)

hemelsiddiquee profile image

hemelsiddiquee 11 months ago

good idea

john 2 months ago

i have sparks comming out the neg.and posi. post what is it

Benjimester profile image

Benjimester Hub Author 2 months ago

That's not good. It's possible that your cables aren't hooked in tightly and causing sparks when the contact comes in and out. When does it spark exactly?

earl pete 2 months ago

i have the same problem when i hook my battery spark come out of neg and posi. start up ok, over nite battery . dead . dead.turn on key no light nother

CELIA 3 weeks ago

I HAVE 95 PLYMOUTH VOYAGER FOR PARTS MY NEW VAN IS A96 DODGE CARAVAN NI USED THE STARTER FROM THE 95 BUT THERE IS STILL NO CLICK 2 THE SOLENOID IS IT MOST LIKELY THE STARTER? Y STARTER IN THE 96 TESTED BAD I WAS TOLD IT WOULD WORK SINCE THEY BOTH CHRYSLERS?? NE HELP? IGNITION MAYBE/

Benjimester profile image

Benjimester Hub Author 3 weeks ago

It definitely could be your solenoid, but I'd double check to make sure that everything's hooked up properly before doing anything more. If you're not hearing a click at all, then either your solenoid or ignition are bad, your starter is completely non-functional, or else something isn't quite hooked up right. Not too sure about the compatibility between those 2 years. I'm not an expert in older Chryslers.

Submit a Comment
Members and Guests

Sign in or sign up and post using a hubpages account.



    • No HTML is allowed in comments, but URLs will be hyperlinked
    • Comments are not for promoting your Hubs or other sites

    Please wait working